A Playbook for Ending the Slavery Exception — and What It Means for Virginia
Virginia's current constitution does not mention slavery. It does not permit it, and it does not prohibit it. That silence leaves every Virginian under the 13th Amendment, which still allows slavery as punishment for a crime. Other states have already closed that gap, and one organization has written down how they did it.
The E Pluribus Unum Fund published Removing the Exception to Slavery from a State Constitution: A Toolkit in May 2024. Kristal Swim wrote it for advocates and lawmakers across the South. We read it closely at Abolish Slavery Virginia. Here is what it teaches, what has changed since it came out, and what it means for our campaign.

Five steps, in plain terms
The toolkit treats abolition as a campaign with a sequence. Each step sets up the next.
Learn the rules. Every state amends its constitution differently. Know how many votes it takes, across how many sessions, and when voters weigh in. Then build a timeline with a backup plan.
Choose the right sponsor. This work outlasts a single session. The toolkit favors a legislator with staying power, a secure seat, a leadership post, and friends in both parties.
Build unusual allies. Businesses, chambers of commerce, faith leaders, and justice groups each open different doors. Agencies that might object should hear from you early, before they organize against you.
Keep the language short. One clear sentence is harder to attack than a page of policy. Extra provisions invite cost estimates and legal confusion.
Tell the public why. Lawmakers, employers, and congregations each need to hear the case in their own terms.
Tennessee shows it can be done in the South
Tennessee voters approved Amendment 3 on November 8, 2022, after a six-year campaign. The toolkit calls Tennessee the first Southern state to ban slavery in its constitution. The new text says: "Slavery and involuntary servitude are forever prohibited."
The coalition is the part worth studying. Bridgestone, AT&T, and Jack Daniel's backed the amendment. The Nashville Chamber of Commerce played a central role, and more than 300 faith leaders signed on.
Supporters framed the vote as right versus wrong, not left versus right.
Tennessee also made a trade. The Department of Correction worried about prison work programs, so sponsors added a second sentence saying incarcerated people may still work. The toolkit presents that as a win. Some advocates read it as a narrower carve-out. Every campaign has to decide where it stands on that question before the drafting starts.
What November 2024 added to the playbook
The toolkit came out six months before two more states voted. Their results sharpen its advice. Nevada voters approved Question 4 in November 2024 with about 60% support. Their ballot asked directly about removing language that authorizes slavery as a criminal punishment.
California voters rejected Proposition 6 the same day, even though no funded opposition campaigned against it. Supporters there said the wording may have confused people. The lesson is to say the word. Voters reject slavery when the ballot calls it slavery. They hesitate when the question is wrapped in softer legal terms.
Colorado adds a second lesson. It removed its exception in 2018, yet incarcerated people sued in 2022 saying they were still forced to work. A constitutional sentence does not enforce itself.
Virginia's task is to add, not remove
The toolkit sorts Southern states into three groups. Seven still carry exception language. Alabama and Tennessee have removed it. Virginia sits in a third group with Florida, South Carolina, Texas, and West Virginia, whose constitutions neither ban nor permit slavery.
So Virginia has no clause to strike. We have a prohibition to write. That is a simpler ask in one respect: nobody has to defend old language, and the amendment can be a single clear sentence.
The rules here are demanding. An amendment must pass the General Assembly twice, with a House of Delegates election in between, and then win a majority of voters. For a measure introduced in the 2027 session, that means a second vote in 2028 and a referendum no earlier than November 2028. Lawmakers moved four amendments through that same two-session process this year, so the path is well worn.
Where you come in
Tennessee won because business owners, pastors, and neighbors all said the same thing to their legislators. Virginia needs that coalition now, before the 2027 session opens.
Call your delegate and state senator. Ask whether they will support adding a ban on slavery to Virginia's constitution.
Bring your organization. Congregations, employers, and community groups can endorse the campaign and add their names.
Share the toolkit. It is free, short, and written for people who have never run a campaign.
Join us at abolishslaveryva.org.
Sources
Removing the Exception to Slavery from a State Constitution: A Toolkit, E Pluribus Unum Fund, May 2024
Nevada Question 4 (2024), Ballotpedia
California Proposition 6 result, CalMatters
California voters reject measure that would have banned forced prison labor, Associated Press via ABC News
Four States Voted to End Slavery, but Not Louisiana, Truthout
House of Delegates passes four constitutional amendments, Cardinal News






Comments